New Tiering proposal

Looking at doing a new tiering structure with 4 categories

Tier 1 Greater than 35% winrate and > 2  matches played.

Tier 2 Decks have won more than 1 game but not in Tier 1.

Tier 3 Decks have played more than 3 matches, still looking for a win.

Tier 4 (NEW) Decks have 3 or less matches and no wins yet.

Tier 1 Narset Greg Alela Connor Lord Windgrace Sam Atla Palani Connor Estrid Sam Niv-Mizzet, Parun Connor K'rrik Greg Obzedat Connor Nahiri Connor Ghave Lee	Tier 2 Atraxa Connor Atraxa Sam Roon Lee Xyris Lee Tana and Tymna Dave Prossh Lee Otrimi Connor Golos Connor Mizzix Greg Phenax Dave Rosheen Connor The Gitrog Monster Connor Purphoros Dave Alesha Sam Yarok Sam
Tier 3 Tasigur Lee Gisela Sam Gavi Sam Meren Greg Anje Greg Korvold Lee Ishai and Reyhan Sam	Tier 4 Teysa Connor Mirri Sam Kemba Dave Karrthus Dave Jhoira Dave Kess Dave Neheb Connor Teneb Dave Vorel Dave Kambal Lee Nekusar Lee Ruric Thar Lee Oloro Greg Chainer Greg Daretti, Scrap Savant Greg

Commander	Player	Tier	Played	Wins	Win%	NewTier
Narset	Greg	1	6	4	67%	1
Alela	Connor	1	6	4	67%	1
Lord Windgrace	Sam	1	7	4	57%	1
Atla Palani	Connor	1	5	3	60%	1
Estrid	Sam	1	8	3	38%	1
Niv-Mizzet, Parun	Connor	1	4	2	50%	1
K'rrik	Greg	1	4	2	50%	1
Obzedat	Connor	1	4	2	50%	1
Nahiri	Connor	1	4	2	50%	1
Ghave	Lee	1	4	2	50%	1
Atraxa	Connor	1	6	2	33%	2
Atraxa	Sam	1	6	2	33%	2
Roon	Lee	1	7	2	29%	2
Xyris	Lee	1	1	1	100%	2
Tana and Tymna	Dave	1	2	1	50%	2
Prossh	Lee	1	2	1	50%	2
Otrimi	Connor	1	2	1	50%	2
Golos	Connor	1	2	1	50%	2
Mizzix	Greg	1	3	1	33%	2
Phenax	Dave	1	3	1	33%	2
Rosheen	Connor	1	4	1	25%	2
The Gitrog Monster	Connor	1	4	1	25%	2
Purphoros	Dave	1	4	1	25%	2
Alesha	Sam	1	4	1	25%	2
Yarok	Sam	1	6	1	17%	2
Teysa	Connor	2	2	0	0%	4
Tasigur	Lee	2	4	0	0%	3
Gisela	Sam	2	4	0	0%	3
Gavi	Sam	2	4	0	0%	3
Mirri	Sam	2	1	0	0%	4
Kemba	Dave	2	3	0	0%	4
Karrthus	Dave	2	1	0	0%	4
Jhoira	Dave	2	2	0	0%	4
Kess	Dave	2	3	0	0%	4
Neheb	Connor	2	2	0	0%	4
Teneb	Dave	2	3	0	0%	4
Vorel	Dave	2	2	0	0%	4
Kambal	Lee	2	2	0	0%	4
Nekusar	Lee	2	1	0	0%	4
Ruric Thar	Lee	2	2	0	0%	4
Oloro	Greg	2	3	0	0%	4
Chainer	Greg	2	2	0	0%	4
Meren	Greg	2	9	0	0%	3
Daretti, Scrap Savant	Greg	2	3	0	0%	4
Anje	Greg	2	6	0	0%	3
Korvold	Lee	2	4	0	0%	3
Ishai and Reyhan	Sam	2	6	0	0%	3

=IF(([@Played]>2)*AND([@[Win%]]>0.35),1,IF([@Wins]>0,2,IF([@Played]>3,3,4)))

EDH Tiering

Don't you love it when you build your latest EDH creation, and bring it to your playgroup all excited, only to see it smashed down when everyone else just breaks out their best deck for its first session?

Does your playgroup do Tiering?  Working out which decks play nicely together and which ones are almost cEDH decks?

We've been keeping track of winners so that we can work out our Tier groups.  Currently I think it feels a bit like this but we still need a bunch more games to work out which results are luck vs real strong wins, and also which wins are against other strong decks.


Tier 1 (winning decks)
Alela
Atraxa
Narset
Rosheen 
Alesha
Niv-Mizzet, Parun
Yarok
Golos
Lord Windgrace
Nahiri
Estrid


Tier 2 (the others)
Nekusar
Ruric Thar
Oloro
Atla Palani
Kambal
Chainer
Daretti, Scrap Savant
Ishai and Reyhan
Roon
Tasigur
Korvold
Meren
Anje